Yesterday at the World Economic Forum, Turkish Prime Minister Erdogan decided to leave the stage of a debate with Shimon Peres to show his "disapprovement". The debate was about the peace process in Israel and the recent war against Hamas in Gaza.
You will probably see the news in all major newspaper today presented as, i simplify, "Shimon Peres apologized to Recep Erdogan". What people will remember and what most media are covering is that: He left and that Shimon Peres apologized (translate Erdogan was right and Peres wrong).Right. Some context? of course not... Now stop, rewind.
You can't understand this if you did not see the debate. I urge you to see the full video below. The argumentation of Erdogan was simply inadequate and wrong (and prior to him the same goes with former egyptian minister Moussa) and President Peres, did just the right thing by reminding the real context in which Israel is operating. It is easy to say that civilians are killed, and that this is not good, that there is a humanitarian crisis in Gaza...But what about the context?
Peres did a great job explaining (in the video it starts at minute 39, just drag the player) with passion the lack of options Israel has in front of a country lead by dictators hiding in Tunnels or in Syria. He's explaining a democracy is not a matter of 1-day election but of civilization, that Israeli totally retreated from Gaza and that even invested in some infrastructures (destroyed by Hamas), that since Israeli retreated missiles where shoot everyday and restrained for many years, that Hamas torture and kill his own people in daylight, that Hamas has a charter where they wrote back on white their mission is to kill every single jew (not israeli, jew). All those are facts. How do you make peace with that? What are your options? What would your country do with that?
Erdogan presented the usual PR Bullshit we are used to hear everyday in the news or on the web: but the reality is where are the options? Where are the choices? This is why Peres told Erdogan, in his case he would have done the same thing.
He reminded something that is not heard enough: Israel wants peace, Israel wants 2 countries, Israel wants Gaza to flourish (that's why we retreated from Gaza), Israel wants victory, not in War (like Hamas always love to claim) but in peace. Can you hear this message from the other side? Yes in part from Fatah and not from Hamas.
Erdogan does not remember there is a difference between Palestinian and Hamas and that peace is not possible with the later, simply because they do not want it and created this situation.
Peres speech was passionate and strong, unusual.
I personally regret he apologized. He was both right on the content and on the way he presented it for about 22 min (After nearly 40 minutes of anti-israeli speech from Erdogan and former egyptian minister moussa). This is why people applauded so strong at the end. I can understand maybe that for diplomatic reasons Peres apologized, but certainly not for what he said, more probably for the context and the way it ended (which you won't read anywhere in the news). Erdogan left, because
he was out of argument (you can feel that in the way he talks and his nervous attitude), not only because he was out of time. I also regret the debate stopped there, because i was curious to hear the answers from Erdogan.
Turkey has recently taken strong positions against Israel surprisingly after having been a moderate and efficient intermediary in the peace process. Why this sudden change? I think you have to look at what happens inside Turkey with the slow but sure progression of Islamism (which is btw creating some issue with the EU integration). Erdogan has in my view a schizophrenic attitude to Israel: he wants to be their friend, but on the other side can't show support towards his own people and public opinion.
Conclusion: the media say "Erdogan left, Shimon Peres Apologized". I say "Erdogan could not hold a debate, Peres defended a brave and honest position". Again do not stop at what you read in the media and see this full video.
What do you say?
Technorati Tags:
WEF worldeconomicforum israel turkey erdogan peres gaza hamas war